Metro Holdings AGM 2025: Major PRC Impairment, Strategic Diversification, and Resilience Amid Global Headwinds

Key Takeaways for Retail Investors from Metro Holdings’ 52nd Annual General Meeting

Metro Holdings Limited’s 52nd AGM, held on July 29, 2025, was a crucial event for shareholders, marked by candid disclosures, strategic pivots, and tough questions regarding the company’s future amid a volatile global landscape. Here’s a comprehensive breakdown of the meeting, with sharp focus on price-sensitive issues and strategic actions that could significantly impact Metro Holdings’ share price.

1. Massive Losses Driven by PRC Real Estate Impairments

• Metro Holdings reported a staggering loss after tax of S\$224.7 million for FY2025, a dramatic reversal from the previous year’s profit of S\$14.6 million. The loss was almost entirely driven by non-cash fair value and impairment losses from its China real estate exposure.
• Losses from PRC investments amounted to approximately S\$230 million, underscoring severe market weakness in China’s property sector. The real estate industry in China, which contributes 25-30% of GDP, has been in decline for four years, with falling prices, rental, and occupancy rates. Asset valuations have been hammered, and many companies have “returned properties back” to banks in Shanghai—a rare and ominous indicator of market distress.
• Metro’s associate, Top Spring International Holdings Ltd (“TSI”), has been a significant contributor to the group’s profits and cash flow in the past, but is now suffering from liquidity issues and is under material uncertainty regarding going concern, as highlighted by its auditor KPMG. TSI’s debt/equity ratio stands at 60-80%, and its shares trade at a deep discount to NAV (HK\$0.50/share vs. NAV of HK\$4/share).
• The loan outstanding from TSI to Metro Group is S\$115.7m (US\$84m), fully secured by three office buildings in Shanghai and land in Hong Kong. While no bank has yet recalled loans, TSI’s ability to recover remains an area of active concern and risk.

2. Strategic Diversification Outside China

• In response to the deepening crisis in China, Metro Holdings has pivoted aggressively towards diversification. Its PRC asset exposure has been reduced from 76% in 2010 to 45% in 2025. No new PRC investments have been made since 2019.
• Key new investments:
  • Australia: JV with Sim Lian has grown to 18 high-quality freehold properties (A\$1.4b portfolio), including office buildings and retail centres. These resilient assets performed well even during Covid.
  • Singapore: Boustead Industrial Fund investment (S\$763m, 15 properties), yielding close to 7%. This is Metro’s first foray into logistics assets.
  • UK: Stake increased to 50% in Fairbriar Real Estate Limited, owner of Middlewood Locks in Manchester, plus partnership on six Purpose-Built Student Accommodation (PBSA) assets valued at £149m. Student housing occupancy rates remain strong, even amid broader market challenges.
  • US/Japan: Investments in Daiwa House Logistics Trust (7.4% stake, portfolio in Japan and Southeast Asia) and United Hampshire US REIT (1.6% stake, East Coast US grocery-anchored retail and self-storage assets).
  • Indonesia: Two projects—Trans Park Bekasi and Trans Park Bintaro—remain slow in sales, with S\$127m “stuck” in unsold residential units.
• Metro Group maintains a robust cash position (S\$298m, 70% in SGD), providing flexibility for further investments or weathering adverse conditions.

3. Retail Business: Legacy vs. Performance

• Metro continues to operate two retail stores (Paragon, Causeway Point), but the business faces structural headwinds and is described as a “sunset industry.” Management insists there’s no plan to close retail for now, but will act in shareholders’ best interest if losses persist.
• Retail contributed S\$94m in revenue, but the segment is under pressure from changing consumer habits and new infrastructure (e.g., Johor Bahru-Singapore RTS Link may impact Causeway Point traffic).
• Shareholders raised concerns about maintaining legacy loss-making retail assets, especially given only 35% Ong family ownership, with the rest held by institutional and public investors. Suggestions included possible privatisation if the intent is to maintain the retail legacy at a loss.

4. Foreign Currency and Interest Rate Risks

• Metro Holdings is exposed to multiple currencies (SGD, RMB, USD, GBP, AUD, IDR). Management employs natural hedges and interest rate swaps to mitigate risk. Current interest rates on borrowings range from 3.6% to 4.7%, depending on currency and jurisdiction.
• Most cash reserves are held in SGD, minimizing currency risk. However, the depreciation of foreign currencies (notably IDR and RMB) and high global interest rates remain risks to earnings and asset valuations.

5. Dividend and Shareholder Returns

• Despite the massive loss, Metro declared a first and final tax-exempt dividend of 2.0 cents per ordinary share for FY2025, to be paid on August 18, 2025. This marks a continued commitment to shareholder returns even during adversity.
• Some shareholders advocated for cash returns instead of further investments, especially questioning the value of investing in external REITs (Daiwa, United Hampshire) where share prices have underperformed.

6. Board and Management Matters

• Performance bonus for Group CEO and Executive Director (39% of total remuneration) was questioned, given the group’s loss. The Remuneration Committee clarified that the bonus computation excludes unrealised losses and is based on a broader range of KPIs, including operational improvements and risk management.
• Directors’ fees remain unchanged for four years, but increased in FY2025 due to two new appointments.
• Mr Ng Ee Peng retired from the Board after four years of service.

7. Price-Sensitive and Strategic Issues

• Shareholders should closely monitor Metro’s exposure to China, especially the performance and liquidity of Top Spring International Holdings, as further impairments or a banking crisis could materially affect asset values and share price.
• The fate of legacy retail assets, and management’s willingness to divest or privatise, could be pivotal for future profitability and investor sentiment.
• Metro’s ability to execute its diversification strategy, manage currency and interest rate risks, and generate steady cash flow from overseas assets will be critical in determining the company’s medium-term growth and resilience.
• Potential asset sales, further impairment losses, or strategic changes (such as buybacks, privatisation, or major divestments) could be share price catalysts.

Conclusion: Is Metro Holdings at an Inflection Point?

Metro Holdings faces a challenging crossroads. The company is absorbing the shockwaves of China’s real estate collapse, pivoting towards diversified global assets, and wrestling with the legacy of its retail business. For retail investors, the current environment is fraught with risk—but also opportunity, should Metro successfully navigate these headwinds and unlock value from its diversified portfolio. Investors should remain alert to developments in China, the performance of key overseas investments, and any corporate actions that might reshape Metro’s future.

Disclaimer

This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. Readers should conduct their own due diligence and consult with financial professionals before making investment decisions. The views expressed herein are based on publicly available information from Metro Holdings’ AGM minutes and are subject to change without notice.

View Metro Historical chart here